Today, I will talk about the case of Jarnail Singh v. Lacchmi Narain Gupta, 2022 SCC OnLine SC 96, wherein the Hon’ble Supreme Court discussed the meaning of ‘obiter dictum’.
Today, I will talk about the case of Jarnail Singh v. Lacchmi Narain Gupta, 2022 SCC OnLine SC 96, wherein the Hon’ble Supreme Court discussed the meaning of ‘obiter dictum’.
To know more about the present post, please visit https://www.desikanoon.co.in/2022/01/what-is-meaning-of-obiter-dictum-or.html
Telegram: https://t.me/Legal_Talks_by_DesiKanoon
YouTube Channel: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCMmVCFV7-Kfo_6S42kPhz2w
Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/legal-talks-by-desikanoon/id1510617120
Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/3KdnziPc4I73VfEcFJa59X?si=vYgrOEraQD-NjcoXA2a7Lg&dl_branch=1&nd=1
Google Podcasts: https://podcasts.google.com/feed/aHR0cHM6Ly9mZWVkcy5zaW1wbGVjYXN0LmNvbS84ZTZTcGREcw?sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwiuz4ifzpLxAhVklGMGHb4HAdwQ9sEGegQIARAD
Amazon Music: https://music.amazon.com/podcasts/4b89fb71-1836-414e-86f6-1116324dd7bc/Legal-Talks-by-Desikanoon
Please subscribe and follow us on YouTube, Instagram, iTunes, Twitter, LinkedIn, Discord, Telegram and Facebook.
Credits:
Music by Wataboi from Pixabay
Thank you for listening!
Hi everyone.
I am Suyash and today, I will talk about the case of Jarnail Singh v. Lacchmi Narain Gupta, 2022 SCC OnLine SC 96, wherein the Hon’ble Supreme Court discussed the meaning of ‘obiter dictum’.
Black’s Law Dictionary, Ninth Edition, defines ‘obiter dictum’ as: -
“A judicial comment made while delivering a judicial opinion, but one that is unnecessary to the decision in the case and therefore not precedential (although it may be considered persuasive).”
Thus, ‘obiter dictum’ is a remark or an opinion expressed by a judge in his decision that is incidentally and not directly related to the question of law before the Court. According to the Court, “it is any statement of law enunciated by the Judge or court merely by way of illustration, argument, analogy, or suggestion…. In the common speech of lawyers, all such extrajudicial expressions of legal opinion are referred to as “dicta”, or “obiter dicta”, these two terms being used interchangeably.”
The Supreme Court also discussed the definition provided in Wharton Law Lexicon (14th Edition) that explains ‘obiter dictum’ as “an opinion not necessary to a judgment” or “an observation as to the law made by a Judge in the course of a case, but not necessary to its decision, and therefore, of no binding effect.”
The Court further noted that “a decision on a point not necessary for the purpose of or which does not fall for determination in that decision becomes an obiter dictum” and “it is a well-settled proposition that only the ratio decidendi can act as the binding or authoritative precedent. Reliance placed on mere general observations or casual expressions of the Court, is not of much avail.”
The Court also cautioned that judges are not oracles and ‘obiter dictum’ does not have any binding effect as such observations are not conclusive in nature. When a judgment is pronounced by a court, “it is not possible for Judges always to express their judgments so as to exclude entirely the risk that in some subsequent case their language may be misapplied and any attempt at such perfection of expression can only lead to the opposite result of uncertainty and even obscurity as regards the case in hand.”
In light of the afore-stated enunciation of law, following important points emerge: -
a. ‘obiter dictum’ is “an observation as to the law made by a Judge in the course of a case, but not necessary to its decision, and therefore, of no binding effect.”
b. “Only the ratio decidendi can act as the binding or authoritative precedent.”
c. ‘Obiter dictum’ does not have any binding effect as such observations are not conclusive in nature.
d. “It is not possible for Judges always to express their judgments so as to exclude entirely the risk that in some subsequent case their language may be misapplied.”
Therefore, I hope that the nature and the meaning of ‘obiter dictum’ is clear by now.
Hence, I hope you enjoyed listening to the show.
Thank you for listening.
Please do not forget to like, subscribe and comment.
See you next time, till then stay tuned.